A review of the book and movie versions of girl interrupted

She was wrongly sent to the hospital, and the movie makes all of her trauma seem to be a joke. This kind of thing brings the movie down. Thursday, December 27, Girl, Interrupted Book: The director was very proud of the actors abilities and their fun atmosphere.

Too much of the dialogue in the movie is clearly aimed directly at the viewer: Less would have been better. The movie came out in The only way to enjoy both is to just think of them as different stories just with the same name.

You know who should have made this movie? Posted by Deniselle at.

I think if I was Susanna Kaysen I would be really unhappy with the way it turned out. In the story she tells of her two year stay in a mental hospital. The fact that a lot of these scenes are Susanna seeing things or experiencing "insane" moments speaks about the weirdly political thread running through this film: They have a lot of fun.

Kaysen wrote about her experiences with insight on the lives of the other patients and their histories.

Girl, Interrupted

Its actually quite tragic. Again, less would have been more.

Unfortunately, almost none of them were used in the movie, and the writers decided to just change the entire story. Susanna and Lisa never ran away. The director was very happy of his weather luck while filming. Charlie Kaufman and Michel Gondry.

She meets a great friend named Lisa, blah blah blah, and they go around the hospital and play instruments together. She was mad at Daisy for mnaming her cat ruby too. Many things were different between the book and the movie.

Book vs. Movie

The scenes added by the screenwriters can be clearly distinguished from the ones based on real events. It almost seems like a joke. Which in itself is fine and to some extent present in the book.

She experienced eighteen long horrible months in McLean and to make the movie so inaccurate and to not take her story seriously seems like a slap in the face.

The movie only took a couple of months to film. Lisa had attempted to escape many times in the book, but nothing remotely close to that scene ever happened. The hospital was under strict watch, one section of the book was even dedicated to the constant checks done by the staff.

It is the same camera angle as when Dorothy goes to Oz and the movie turns to color. Reading the book really made the movie seem insincere. Winona Ryder is good, but the character of Susanna has been blanded down a bit too much and fails to make the impression she makes in the book.

I thought at first it was a dream sequence, but no. Kaysen really has an original voice as an author, and her insights were interesting to read.Book vs.

Girl Interrupted

Movie Having seen the movie years before I read the book, I was shocked by how different each version of Girl, Interrupted was. Susanna Kaysen wrote Girl, Interrupted as a recount of her eighteen months as McLean Hospital in the s.

Girl Interrupted This Book/Movie Report Girl Interrupted and other 64,+ term papers, college essay examples and free essays are available now on mi-centre.com Autor: review • September 20, • Book/Movie Report • Words (2 Pages) • 1, Views4/4(1).

Despite it's amazing performances from all of the cast members, after reading the novel, this movie is not an insult to the novel, but an insult to the real life Lisa Rowe.

They made her out to be a cold-blooded and harmful person, and also made it so that Lisa was the reason another character commits suicide. None of that ever happened in the book. The unreliability of the first-person-narrator is not only a question when dealing with the book, but it is also an interesting aspect to consider when taking a closer look at the cinematic version of Girl, Interrupted.

In order to analyze how Kaysen's literary work was adapted, I will first shortly introduce the book and the movie. The unreliability of the first-person-narrator is not only a question when dealing with the book, but it is also an interesting aspect to consider when taking a closer look at the cinematic version of Girl, Interrupted.

Jan 14,  · A supervising nurse played by Whoopi Goldberg offers her own diagnosis: "You are a lazy, self-indulgent little girl who is driving yourself crazy." Winona Ryder plays Susanna Kaysen, whose real-life memoir tells of how she lost two years of her life by stumbling onto the psychiatric conveyor belt/5.

Download
A review of the book and movie versions of girl interrupted
Rated 5/5 based on 21 review